Results of the XIX Congress of Judges: the operational HCJ and questions for its new members - BD1CE
Back

Results of the XIX Congress of Judges: the operational HCJ and questions for its new members

Читати україїнською.

Today, the Congress of judges elected three more members of the HCJ: Tetyana Bondarenko, Olena Kovbiy and… Serhiy Burlakov. The public had the most serious questions for the latter, in particular, regarding his visits to the Russian Federation and Crimea after its annexation and connections with Oleksandr Feldman, the former member of the already banned “Opposition Platform – For Life” party.

Thus, over these two days, the judges elected the worst among the 16 candidates recommended by the Ethics Council. The judges also demonstrated their unpreparedness for real agents of change in the judicial system.

The High Council of Justice will fully resume its work tomorrow since it has 15 members, the minimum number to become operational. We will evaluate the new team based on their decisions; the new HCJ has a chance to disprove the doubts of the public. The next decisions of the HCJ will be the election of the Head and the Deputy Head of the HCJ. After that, it will be possible to draw the first conclusions.

Yesterday, January 11, the Congress of Judges elected five members of the HCJ: Yuliya Bokova, Alla Kotelevets, Hryhoriy Usyk, Oleksandr Sasevych and Olha Popikova. Unfortunately, the public had questions for each of the elected members of the HCJ. It is unknown whether they refuted the doubts about their integrity since the interviews were closed. Information about the newly elected members of the HCJ can be found here.

Other news
To the section
The Committee recommended adopting an even worse draft law than the one criticised by the Venice Commission
The Committee recommended adopting an even worse draft law than the one criticised by the Venice Commission

On 30 September, the Verkhovna Rada Committee on Legal Policy recommended that Parliament adopt, as a basis, draft law No. 16018 on competitions for the High Qualifications Commission of Judges and the High Council of Justice. The authors of the draft law are Volodymyr Vatras, Ivan Kalaur and Mykola...

Venice Commission has criticised the government’s model of selection to the HQCJ
Venice Commission has criticised the government’s model of selection to the HQCJ

The High Qualifications Commission of Judges (HQCJ) selects candidates for judicial positions and evaluates sitting judges. Its decisions determine who will work in Ukrainian courts. That is why it is crucial who selects the members of the HQCJ itself, and under what rules. In 2027, almost the entir...

Izovitova is concealing the decision that has allowed her to lead the attorney profession for 14 years
Izovitova is concealing the decision that has allowed her to lead the attorney profession for 14 years

On the left in the image is Serhii Osyka, an attorney and member of the Bar Council of Ukraine (BCU). In 2022, he took part in adopting the BCU decision that allows Medvedchuk’s associate Lidiia Izovitova to avoid elections within the attorney profession and to lead it for the 14th year now. Izovi...