Cleansing in action: the High Council of Justice dismisses judge Otrosh from the list of 180 low-integrity judges - F21D6
Back

Cleansing in action: the High Council of Justice dismisses judge Otrosh from the list of 180 low-integrity judges

On October 10, the High Council of Justice (HCJ) took a step towards cleansing the judiciary. By majority vote, the notorious judge Inna Otrosh was dismissed. The dissenting votes came from Serhii Burlakov, Vitalii Salikhov, and Inna Plakhtii.

During the hearing, rapporteur Oleh Kandziuba emphasized his recommendation to dismiss Inna Otrosh based on a Supreme Court ruling that rejected her lawsuit. However, this victory is not final, as over 170 other judges on the “list of 180” still have a chance to fight their cases.

We express our gratitude to the HCJ for its constructive and objective decision, which will strengthen public trust in the judiciary.

The High Qualification Commission of Judges (HQCJ) has also taken a stance on judges influenced by the Supreme Court’s decision regarding judge Usaty.

Who is Inna Otrosh?

  • Since the beginning of Russia’s military aggression in 2014, Otrosh has regularly travelled to the temporarily occupied territory of Crimea and twice to the Russian Federation, particularly to Saint Petersburg.
  • As the daughter of Otrosh Sr., a powerful figure from Yanukovych’s regime, Otrosh Jr. claimed there was no active combat in Crimea and that the state did not resist Russian occupation. She argued that, as an “ordinary citisen,” she had the right to vacation there.
  • Moreover, her mother not only likely facilitated her transfer to a Kyiv court but also gifted her large amounts of valuable property, from luxury cars to apartments in central Kyiv.
Other news
To the section
New rules bring new risks. What the draft law on the selection of HCJ members changes
New rules bring new risks. What the draft law on the selection of HCJ members changes

The government’s draft law submitted to the Venice Commission for consideration, in addition to a new procedure for forming the HQCJ, also substantially changes the procedures for electing (appointing) members of the High Council of Justice (HCJ). The proposed changes may create new risks for...

The government proposes a “broken bicycle” for international experts in the commission selecting HQCJ members
The government proposes a “broken bicycle” for international experts in the commission selecting HQCJ members

The High Qualifications Commission of Judges (HQCJ) is a body that can recommend a person for the position of judge or recommend their dismissal. That is, whoever decides your case, should you suddenly have to go to court, depends on the HQCJ’s assessment. Judges over judges, so to speak. Logi...

DACK cases and judges can end up in the same court again
DACK cases and judges can end up in the same court again

The High Qualifications Commission of Judges (HQCJ) has recommended transferring 6 judges of the liquidated DACK to the Kyiv District Administrative Court (KDAC). All the cases of the liquidated DACK had previously been transferred to the KDAC as well. In other words, the nameplate has changed, but...

Special by topic
To the section
THE “REBOOTED” HIGH COUNCIL OF JUSTICE:WINS AND FAILS
Judicial reform roadmap