A year of consideration of disciplinary cases: how HCJ members work - 2FE72
Support
UA EN
Back
A year of consideration of disciplinary cases: how HCJ members work
HCJ

A year of consideration of disciplinary cases: how HCJ members work

In this material, we are going to look at the statistics of the HCJ’s activity overall and its individual members between November 1, 2023, and October 31, 2024, and point out the most significant cases that were reviewed, or not, in the second six months after the disciplinary function of the HCJ was restored. This overview will help us analyze the productivity of each specific HCJ member and give us a chance to compare the productivity of the SDI with the HCJ in the future, while also recording the “disciplinary heritage” that the latter will pass on to the SDI.


The research has been carried out with the financial support of the German Foreign Ministry. The views and positions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the position of the German Foreign Ministry.

View
Library
To the section
Turning Crisis into Opportunity: Judicial Reform, Democratic Resilience, and Ukraine’s EU Future
Turning Crisis into Opportunity: Judicial Reform, Democratic Resilience, and Ukraine’s EU Future
Constitutional Court HCJ HQCJ Supreme Court
7 Misconceptions about Judicial Reform in Ukraine
7 Misconceptions about Judicial Reform in Ukraine
HCJ HQCJ Supreme Court
Rule of law, justice, and fundamental rights in Ukraine: Shadow Report
Rule of law, justice, and fundamental rights in Ukraine: Shadow Report
HCJ HQCJ
Ukrainian Justice with Russian Passport: the Process of (Non-)Verification of Citizenship in Regard to Representatives of the Judiciary
Ukrainian Justice with Russian Passport: the Process of (Non-)Verification of Citizenship in Regard to Representatives of the Judiciary
Constitutional Court HCJ HQCJ Supreme Court
News
To the section
New rules bring new risks. What the draft law on the selection of HCJ members changes
New rules bring new risks. What the draft law on the selection of HCJ members changes

The government’s draft law submitted to the Venice Commission for consideration, in addition to a new procedure for forming the HQCJ, also substantially changes the procedures for electing (appointing) members of the High Council of Justice (HCJ). The proposed changes may create new risks for...

HCJ
Ethics Council recommends candidates for the High Council of Justice
Ethics Council recommends candidates for the High Council of Justice

On 14 July, the Ethics Council found five candidates for the High Council of Justice to meet the criteria of professional ethics and integrity. They are Iryna Davydovych, Oleksandr Zhytnyi, Lesia Muzyka, Ivan Nazarov, and Tetiana Tsuvina. Five candidates were found not to meet the criteria. They are...

HCJ
A draft law has been registered in the Rada to make judges’ disciplinary liability more effective
A draft law has been registered in the Rada to make judges’ disciplinary liability more effective

Draft Law No. 15374 has been registered in the Verkhovna Rada. It is intended to prevent the High Council of Justice’s work from grinding to a halt in the spring of 2027 and to make judges’ disciplinary liability more effective and predictable. The adoption of this draft law is one of Uk...

HCJ Verkhovna Rada
Special
To the section
THE “REBOOTED” HIGH COUNCIL OF JUSTICE:WINS AND FAILS
THE “REBOOTED” HIGH COUNCIL OF JUSTICE:WINS AND FAILS
Judicial reform roadmap
Judicial reform roadmap