The HQCJ takes steps to improve access to judges’ dossiers for the PIC and PCIE

Last week, the High Qualification Commission of Judges (HQCJ) took an important first step in addressing the long-standing issue of granting the Public Integrity Council (PIC) and the Public Council of International Experts (PCIE) proper access to judges’ dossiers. The HQCJ approved a draft amendment to its internal regulations, allowing the PIC and PCIE to copy, store, and process information about judges necessary for their assessments. The proposed changes will now be sent to the Council of Judges and the High Council of Justice (HCJ) for consultation.

Is the problem fully resolved?

Unfortunately, risks remain. The Council of Judges and the HCJ provide recommendations that are not legally binding, unlike the potential stance of the Supreme Court. It has previously demonstrated its ability to create legal grounds for recognizing 180 judges of low integrity as fit for office. There is a substantial risk that it may now decide that granting such access to judges’ dossiers exceeds legal boundaries.

Despite these risks, DEJURE Foundation welcomes the HQCJ’s decision. Ensuring access to judges’ dossiers is critical for cleansing the judiciary of unfit judges, which directly impacts Ukraine’s progress toward EU membership.