Kivalov’s legacy and the monopoly of “special” universities: What’s wrong with the Congress of Legal Scholars that elects members of the HCJ? - 9FB68

Newsroom

Who will select judges of the Constitutional Court? The Cabinet of Ministers appointed international experts, with two more Ukrainian experts to come
Who will select judges of the Constitutional Court? The Cabinet of Ministers appointed international experts, with two more Ukrainian experts to come

On October 13, the Cabinet of Ministers granted approval to an esteemed panel of international experts tasked with selecting judges for the Constitutional Court. The distinguished experts include: Hanna Suchocka, the 5th Prime Minister of Poland and honorary president of the Venice Commission. Aleš...

Because of one judge, the qualification assessment of two thousand judges is at risk. Will the new HQCJ bend under him?
Because of one judge, the qualification assessment of two thousand judges is at risk. Will the new HQCJ bend under him?

Today, the High Qualification Commission of Judges will determine the schedule for reviewing the qualification assessment results of Judge Vilchynskyi. Let’s revisit the notable aspects of this controversial judge’s history: In 2019, the Public Integrity Council recognised Vilchynsky a...

The Ethics Council will publish the interviews with current members and candidates for the HCJ
The Ethics Council will publish the interviews with current members and candidates for the HCJ

The Ethics Council has announced its intention to publish the interviews conducted with members of the HCJ and candidates for positions. Over the course of a year and a half, approximately a hundred such interviews were conducted. Despite requests from ten candidates and current HCJ members, includi...

The President has recently initiated a competition for the second member’s position within the High Council of Justice (HCJ) under his quota. No one has been appointed to the first position yet.
The President has recently initiated a competition for the second member’s position within the High Council of Justice (HCJ) under his quota. No one has been appointed to the first position yet.

The President made the timely announcement of a competition for the second member of the High Council of Justice under his quota. This decision comes as the HCJ is preparing to review disciplinary complaints against judges, and there are already approximately nine thousand such complaints, making it...

“Schemes” discovered that the retired judge of the Civil Court of Cassation within the Supreme Court, Valentyna Simonenko, has a Russian passport
“Schemes” discovered that the retired judge of the Civil Court of Cassation within the Supreme Court, Valentyna Simonenko, has a Russian passport

As reported by “Schemes” journalists, Valentyna Simonenko, a former judge from the Civil Court of Cassation within the Supreme Court, possesses a Russian passport and is currently enjoying an honourable retirement. Starting from April 2023, she receives a monthly sum of approximately U...

The Supreme Court supported the draft law on the “manual” Grand Chamber
The Supreme Court supported the draft law on the “manual” Grand Chamber

At the Plenum, the Supreme Court supported MP Pavlish’s draft law No. 9643-1 on changing the structure of the Grand Chamber, which foresees creating a weak and dependent Grand Chamber. Notably, the decision received 75 votes in favour, while 31 votes opposed it during the Plenum session. It&#...

The HCJ increased the number of the HACC judges. What will happen with the competition?
The HCJ increased the number of the HACC judges. What will happen with the competition?

Following the HCJ’s decision, the High Anti-Corruption Court will have a total of 42 judges in the first instance court and 21 judges in the appellate court, adding 24 positions compared to the previous arrangement. The next step involves the High Qualification Commission of Judges (HQCJ) org...

Yanukovych’s henchman and Vovk’s accomplice: the Council of Judges elected Yaroslav Romanyuk and Volodymyr Kuzmenko to the selection commission for the Constitutional Court
Yanukovych’s henchman and Vovk’s accomplice: the Council of Judges elected Yaroslav Romanyuk and Volodymyr Kuzmenko to the selection commission for the Constitutional Court

The Council of Judges appointed Yaroslav Romanyuk, who served as the head of the Supreme Court of Ukraine during the Yanukovych era, to join the commission responsible for selecting judges for the Constitutional Court. 

The President delays the appointment of a member of the HCJ under his quota
The President delays the appointment of a member of the HCJ under his quota

In April, the commission responsible for recommending candidates for the High Council of Justice (HCJ) sent a list of potential appointees for vacant positions to the President. However, it is now September, and there is still no update.

Vovk against the Service of Disciplinary Inspectors: MP Slavytska tried to break the transparent competition by conflicting provisions in the new law
Vovk against the Service of Disciplinary Inspectors: MP Slavytska tried to break the transparent competition by conflicting provisions in the new law

Today, the Verkhovna Rada adopted the draft law on competition for the Service of Disciplinary Inspectors (No. 9483-2). It is on this draft law that the start of consideration of complaints against judges and their dismissals depends. Additionally, it introduces a competitive selection process for...

The MPs will resume the consideration of disciplinary complaints against judges, but they intend to sabotage the competition for the SDI
The MPs will resume the consideration of disciplinary complaints against judges, but they intend to sabotage the competition for the SDI

Tomorrow, the MPs can finally start the consideration of disciplinary complaints against judges. They are planning to vote on draft law No. 9261, which, in particular, proposes to provide the High Council of Justice with the opportunity to consider complaints as soon as the law on transparent compet...

Kivalov’s legacy and the monopoly of “special” universities: What’s wrong with the Congress of Legal Scholars that elects members of the HCJ?
Kivalov’s legacy and the monopoly of “special” universities: What’s wrong with the Congress of Legal Scholars that elects members of the HCJ?

On September 21, 2023, the Congress of Legal Scholars will be convened once again to elect one member of the High Council of Justice. The last Congress, which took place on June 2, 2023, could not elect anyone since none of the candidates got the majority of votes.

Load more