HQCJ:Accomplishments and Problems - AA532
Related materials
To the section
The government proposes a “broken bicycle” for international experts in the commission selecting HQCJ members
The government proposes a “broken bicycle” for international experts in the commission selecting HQCJ members

The High Qualifications Commission of Judges (HQCJ) is a body that can recommend a person for the position of judge or recommend their dismissal. That is, whoever decides your case, should you suddenly have to go to court, depends on the HQCJ’s assessment. Judges over judges, so to speak. Logi...

DACK cases and judges can end up in the same court again
DACK cases and judges can end up in the same court again

The High Qualifications Commission of Judges (HQCJ) has recommended transferring 6 judges of the liquidated DACK to the Kyiv District Administrative Court (KDAC). All the cases of the liquidated DACK had previously been transferred to the KDAC as well. In other words, the nameplate has changed, but...

Who will select the future members of the HQCJ, and why judicial reform will be at risk without international experts
Who will select the future members of the HQCJ, and why judicial reform will be at risk without international experts

Who ends up on the Selection Commission will determine the future composition of the HQCJ — and therefore, who will go on to select and assess Ukrainian judges. On July 21, the Council of Judges of Ukraine (CoJ) announced an additional round of selection of candidates to the Selection Commission...

Honourable escape: how DACK judge Kuzmenko avoided assessment and secured lifetime payments
Honourable escape: how DACK judge Kuzmenko avoided assessment and secured lifetime payments

The High Council of Justice (HCJ) has retired judge Anna Kuzmenko of the dissolved District Administrative Court of Kyiv (DACK), who had been issuing rulings at the direction of the court’s former notorious head, Pavlo Vovk. Kuzmenko is 43 years old and will now receive a lifetime monthly allo...

The Supreme Court may overturn the results of eight years of judicial clean-up: a key decision in the case of Inna Otrosh
The Supreme Court may overturn the results of eight years of judicial clean-up: a key decision in the case of Inna Otrosh

The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court may issue a final ruling in the case of Inna Otrosh, a former judge of the Kyiv Commercial Court who was dismissed after failing her qualification assessment. If Otrosh is reinstated, it will send a dangerous signal across the entire system: that one can blatan...

The Otrosh case (and more): what decision will the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court adopt?
The Otrosh case (and more): what decision will the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court adopt?

Today’s hearing on the reinstatement of Inna Otrosh ended without a decision. The case was postponed until December 11 at 14:00. Otrosh was supported by her long-time allies: Maidan judges Taras Zaiets and Oksana Tsarevych, as well as Rostyslav Kravets — one of the figures featured in the “...