Judicial reform: a fresh start is needed - C2603
Back
Judicial reform: a fresh start is needed

Judicial reform: a fresh start is needed

The judicial reform which began after the Revolution of Dignity has been the most substantial in the history of independent Ukraine. Have the reforms achieved their goals? What are the successes and failures of the reforms and what are their causes? Which reforms should Ukraine continue to implement in order to raise public confidence in the judiciary and improve the efficiency of the administration of justice? The goal of this policy brief is to provide answers to these questions.

This brief briefly describes and assesses Ukraine’s major judicial reforms after the Revolution of Dignity. This brief also sets forth recommendations for improving the current state of affairs, primarily a change in the fundamental formation of the bodies making decisions on judicial careers.

View
New rules bring new risks. What the draft law on the selection of HCJ members changes
New rules bring new risks. What the draft law on the selection of HCJ members changes

The government’s draft law submitted to the Venice Commission for consideration, in addition to a new procedure for forming the HQCJ, also substantially changes the procedures for electing (appointing) members of the High Council of Justice (HCJ). The proposed changes may create new risks for...

The government proposes a “broken bicycle” for international experts in the commission selecting HQCJ members
The government proposes a “broken bicycle” for international experts in the commission selecting HQCJ members

The High Qualifications Commission of Judges (HQCJ) is a body that can recommend a person for the position of judge or recommend their dismissal. That is, whoever decides your case, should you suddenly have to go to court, depends on the HQCJ’s assessment. Judges over judges, so to speak. Logi...

DACK cases and judges can end up in the same court again
DACK cases and judges can end up in the same court again

The High Qualifications Commission of Judges (HQCJ) has recommended transferring 6 judges of the liquidated DACK to the Kyiv District Administrative Court (KDAC). All the cases of the liquidated DACK had previously been transferred to the KDAC as well. In other words, the nameplate has changed, but...

Bar Reform Roadmap
Supreme Court Unmasked: Corruption, Opposing Reforms and Russian Passports
Judicial Reform Roadmap