DEJURE Foundation filed a complaint against Serhiy Burlakov, a member of the HCJ. He is delaying the consideration of the disciplinary case against Vsevolod Knyazev - 0965C

Newsroom

Is political influence on judiciary making a comeback? The Verkhovna Rada is going to vote on a draft law that will make judges dependent on the Office of the President
Is political influence on judiciary making a comeback? The Verkhovna Rada is going to vote on a draft law that will make judges dependent on the Office of the President

The Verkhovna Rada is set to vote on a contentious draft law No. 9439 on Thursday, May 9. This draft law aims to reintroduce the influence of the Office of the President in the judicial appointment process, a move that has raised significant concerns about the independence of the judiciary. Under th...

(Un)cleansing the judiciary? The HQCJ continues to ignore the opinions of the Public Integrity Council
(Un)cleansing the judiciary? The HQCJ continues to ignore the opinions of the Public Integrity Council

As the sixth month of judicial qualifications assessments progresses, the High Qualification Commission of Judges (HQCJ) has evaluated 118 judges. However, despite 68 of these judges receiving negative opinions of the Public Integrity Council (PIC), the HQCJ has often overturned these opinions: In 3...

Academic dishonesty – not a problem? The HQCJ needs consistency in judge assessment criteria
Academic dishonesty – not a problem? The HQCJ needs consistency in judge assessment criteria

At the end of last year, the High Qualification Commission of Judges (HQCJ) and the Public Integrity Council (PIC) approved joint indicators for assessing judges, specifically highlighting issues of low integrity. But is the HQCJ truly adhering to these indicators? On Monday, April 29, the HQCJ deci...

Competent enough. Five out of eight candidates for the CCU advance
Competent enough. Five out of eight candidates for the CCU advance

Today, on May 2nd, the Advisory Group of Experts (AGE) announced the candidates for the Constitutional Court who have passed the legal competence assessment. Out of 8 candidates, 5 received the “qualified” rating: Yuriy Barabash, Oleksandr Vodyannikov, and Serhiy Riznyk under the quota o...

Not noticed anything: The High Qualification Council of Judges allowed low-integrity judges Kovalenko and Kovalchuk to retain their positions
Not noticed anything: The High Qualification Council of Judges allowed low-integrity judges Kovalenko and Kovalchuk to retain their positions

The High Qualification Commission of Judges (HQCJ) continues to overturn negative opinions of the Public Integrity Council (PIC),  allowing low-integrity judges to retain their positions: today, 10 out of 14 Commission members voted to keep Pavlo Kovalenko and Olena Kovalchuk in their positions. ...

The High Council of Justice initiated 4 disciplinary cases against Vovk and Ablov
The High Council of Justice initiated 4 disciplinary cases against Vovk and Ablov

The High Council of Justice (HCJ) has finally initiated four disciplinary cases against the District Administrative Court of Kyiv (DACK) judges: three against the notorious head of the DACK Pavlo Vovk, and one against Yevheniy Ablov. All complaints are based on well-known National Anti-Corruption Bu...

Will the Supreme Court put the qualification assessment in jeopardy? “Maidan judge” Klyuchnyk appeals the decision of the HQCJ
Will the Supreme Court put the qualification assessment in jeopardy? “Maidan judge” Klyuchnyk appeals the decision of the HQCJ

“Maidan judge” Andriy Klyuchnyk decided to join the “cohort” of his colleagues who decided to contest the HQCJ’s ruling that declared him unfit for his position by appealing to the Supreme Court. His case is scheduled for a hearing on May 27. Klyuchnyk was among the initial jud...

Just because he can: the HCJ did not bring to responsibility judge Kovhanych, who doubled the speed limit, threatened and ran over a policeman’s foot and fled the scene
Just because he can: the HCJ did not bring to responsibility judge Kovhanych, who doubled the speed limit, threatened and ran over a policeman’s foot and fled the scene

Today, on April 17, the High Council of Justice (HCJ) concluded that Serhiy Kovhanych, a judge from the Tulchyn district court in the Vinnytsia region, should not be held accountable. Although Roman Maselko, who is a reporting member of the HCJ in this case, recommended the judge’s dismissal...

32 against 22. Does the HQCJ agree with the negative opinions of the Public Integrity Council?
32 against 22. Does the HQCJ agree with the negative opinions of the Public Integrity Council?

After five months of the qualification assessment, the results are as follows: Meetings were conducted by the HQCJ concerning 112 judges. The HQCJ reviewed 62 judges with negative opinions of the PIC. In 32 instances, the HQCJ overturned negative opinions of the PIC, allowing these judges to retain...

A small step forward – the Ministry of Education and Science adopted admission rules to law schools in 2024
A small step forward – the Ministry of Education and Science adopted admission rules to law schools in 2024

In March, the Ministry of Education and Science (MES) enacted the admission rules for higher education, including law, in 2024. This regulation makes slight progress in establishing just and reasonable law school admission requirements and aligning legal education with European standards. Positive c...

Judge Kuchma to the Security Service of Ukraine representatives at the Lvov case hearing: “The attendees in the courtroom appear to be more informed about this matter.”
Judge Kuchma to the Security Service of Ukraine representatives at the Lvov case hearing: “The attendees in the courtroom appear to be more informed about this matter.”

Sighs and gestures of helplessness – this is roughly how the Security Service of Ukraine (SSU) representative looked today during the Lvov case proceeding at the Sixth Administrative Court of Appeal. Today, on March 28, the panel of judges chaired by Andriy Kuchma initiated considering the Sup...

DEJURE Foundation filed a complaint against Serhiy Burlakov, a member of the HCJ. He is delaying the consideration of the disciplinary case against Vsevolod Knyazev
DEJURE Foundation filed a complaint against Serhiy Burlakov, a member of the HCJ. He is delaying the consideration of the disciplinary case against Vsevolod Knyazev

Today, on April 11, a complaint was lodged against Serhiy Burlakov, a member of the HCJ, accusing him of stalling the disciplinary proceedings concerning Vsevolod Knyazev. Previously, in June 2023, our lawyer, Marta Bereza, filed a complaint against Vsevolod Knyazev for alleged bribery. Such grave m...

Load more